skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From R. T. Wright   2 August 1879

9 Victoria Terrace, Aldershot

2 Aug, 1879

Sir,

Pardon my addressing you as a stranger, but I hope you will excuse the liberty I take in writing to you when I mention it is only to inform you where you will find some curious facts relating to your studies.—

When I was in India I met the Stud Commission on their tour of inspection which led to their report on perusing which the Government of India gave up horse-breeding in Bengal.—1

The Commission consisted of Major-General Crawford Chamberlain, President, (now Commanding the Lucknow division, & the members were Colonel Ravenhill, Royal Horse Artillery, & Mr. Hallen, Principal Veterinary Surgeon.—2 I met them before their tour was complete, but they told me such interesting facts that when I came home I applied at the India Office for information if the report had been published or not.— As I am only a junior officer, (a surgeon of ten years’ service, passed for promotion, I was not very much surprised to receive no answer, so I asked Col. Ravenhill about it, now that he has come home & is stationed at Canterbury.—

I inclose you his reply, as you see by it that he quite agrees with me about the desirability of printing the Stud Commission report, & suggests that a question in the House of Commons might effect the object.—

However a savant like yourself, Sir, might perhaps have access to the report of the Studs at the India Office without worrying Govt. at the end of the Session, & no doubt you would be enabled to make what use you chose of the materials placed at your disposal, which are now lost in official pigeon-holes.—

The Studs were abolished because the damp climate of Bengal proper had a most deteriorating effect on the horses bred in them, though the stock was continually being replenished by arabs, & by thoroughbred horses & mares imported from England at enormous expense.—3

The Commission report is illustrated by photographs of the horses, some of which were shown to me.—

In covering up all the photograph but the head, you would think it was the likeness of a sheep or a goat, for the profile of the face was convex instead of flat & straight; the eyes looked outwards, & apparently not at all to the front; the ears were long & drooping outwards languidly, not “pricked” briskly, & the whole aspect of the animal was decidedly “sheepish” & stupid, though the sires & dams were very handsome & intelligent.—

They had ring bones as big as your head, pasterns as long as your arm, & every conceivable equine disease—

The hoofs were split like those of oxen, not merely on the front, but also underneath, the animal’s foot being held up to let the ground surface of it be photographed— The crack was two inches in depth.—4

These Studs were in Behar, the garden of India, the most North Western part of Lower Bengal, a most lovely place each depôt was, but the damp is fatal.—5

On the contrary in the Punjab, at the Salt Range, between Jhelum, Rawal Pindi & Pind Dadun Khan,6 where the herbage is hardly visible, the ground is baked & the sky is a furnace, both horses & cattle flourish in the dry heat almost as much as they do in England, so the Studs are now removed thither.—

Yrs. respectfully | R. Temple Wright

⁠⟨⁠Surg⁠⟩⁠eon, Bengal army

[Enclosure]

R.H.A. Barracks | Canterbury

July 28th. 1879

Dear Mr Wright

Absence from here & travelling about has prevented my answering your letter of the 13th. inst

The Report of the late Stud Commission in Bengal has never been published   it would be a most curious thing to put in Darwin’s hands & substantiate much he sets forth,7

Of course they have it at the India Office, I should say, & if you cannot get it to look at, you should get a Member of Parliament to ask in the House, for the report to be published, in detail, as a most interesting Assistance to Breeders of Horses & cattle everywhere.

Yes, the old Chesnut Troop* has entirely changed of late years—, but it still keeps up its great reputation; and has first rate Officers with it now—

Should you come this way I hope you will look us up—& Believe me | Yours truly | F. G. Ravenhill—

*i.e. A. Battery, A. Brigade Royal Horse Artillery formerly commanded by Col. Ravenhill—

The battery is commonly called the “Chestnut Troop” because all the horses are of that colour—

It is renowned for its smartness in the Service, but in India it was regarded by the natives with almost veneration for they have a curious superstition that if you go into battle on a chestnut charger you are certain to escape unhurt.—

R. T. W.8

Footnotes

For details of the Special Stud Commission’s work and their reasons for recommending the abolition of horse breeding in Bengal, see Hallen 1887.
Crawford Trotter Chamberlain, Frederick George Ravenhill, and James Herbert Brockencote Hallen. While serving as acting inspecting veterinary surgeon of the Bengal army, Hallen was a member of the Special Stud Commission from December 1872 to March 1876 (Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 24 (1901–3): 645).
The final report of the Special Stud Commission was never published, but the Stud Department of the Government of India was replaced by two departments: Army Remount Operations and Horse-breeding Operations (Hallen 1887, p. 181).
Ringbone is a lameness disease of the pastern and coffin joints, and is degenerative and incurable. Long pasterns lead to hyperextension of the fetlock and possible lameness. Split hoof is most frequently a result of fungal infection in damp conditions.
CD described high humidity as a problem for horses in Variation 1: 53.
Jhelum, Rawalpindi, and Pind Dadan Khan are now in Pakistan.
CD had considered the inheritance of characteristics and diseases of the horse in Variation 1: 49–61 and 2: 10–11.
‘*i.e. ... R. T. W.’ in Wright’s hand.

Bibliography

Hallen, James Herbert Brockencote. 1887. Government horse-breeding in India. [Read 6 May 1887.] Journal of the United Service Institution of India 15: 177–97.

Variation: The variation of animals and plants under domestication. By Charles Darwin. 2 vols. London: John Murray. 1868.

Summary

Lack of success in breeding horses in Bengal is related to damp climate. Encloses letter from F. G. Ravenhill concerning an unpublished report by the Stud Commission on animal breeds in Bengal.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-12178
From
Robert Temple Wright
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Aldershot
Source of text
DAR 181: 177
Physical description
ALS 8pp, encl 4pp

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 12178,” accessed on 26 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-12178.xml

letter