skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From S. H. Vines   24 November [1881]1

Christs College— | Cambridge

Nov. 24.

My dear Mr. Darwin,

I hope in a day or two to have an opportunity of seeing the granular cells in the roots, and to try to find out something of their meaning— Your observation that the root-hairs spring from cells which are not granular is very interesting and suggestive, & I will not fail to note this point—2 The point which I shall especially try to make out is as to whether or not this appearance is undoubtedly due to some difference between the various cells of the root whilst they are still alive— possibly it may be induced to some extent in the process of preparation—

My suggestion that 10 per cent salt solution should be tried as a solvent, is based upon my experience of this reagent with regard to the aleurone-grains which the cells of seeds contain— most of these proteid grains dissolve to some extent in this fluid, and some of them completely—3 I hoped that possibly the granules in these root-cells might be found to be soluble in it also, and this would afford some clue as to their probable nature— They seem to belong to the protoplasm at any rate—

yours faithfully | Sydney H. Vines.

CD annotations

2.3 proteid grains] underl red crayon
2.3 extent … completely— 2.4] underl red crayon
2.4 I hoped … any rate— 2.6] scored pencil

Footnotes

The year is established by the relationship between this letter and the letter to S. H. Vines, 22 November 1881.
CD had observed granular matter in the root cells and rootlets of Euphorbia (spurge) and Pelargonium (see letter to S. H. Vines, 22 November 1881).
See letter to S. H. Vines, 22 November 1881 and n. 4. The aleurone is a layer of cells coating the endosperm of seeds of grains and some dicotyledons with a persistent endosperm (see letter from S. H. Vines, 2 November [1881] and n. 4). A proteid was defined as a large group of compounds, also known as ‘albumineous’.

Summary

Will observe the granular cells in roots, to investigate CD’s observation that root-hairs spring from cells that are not granular. Hopes they may be soluble in [carbonate of ammonia] solution.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-13509
From
Sydney Howard Vines
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Christ’s College, Cambridge
Source of text
DAR 62: 1
Physical description
ALS 2pp †

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 13509,” accessed on 5 June 2025, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-13509.xml

letter