skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From A. G. Butler   13 December 1879

Zool. Dept. | British Museum

13th. Dec. 1879

My dear Sir,

The female of Ornithoptera magellanus is slightly shot with opaline, but not by any means to the same extent as the male, the hindwings are also heavily spotted with black as in the allied forms.1

We have 18 species of the yellow-winged group, but O. magellanus is the only one which shows an opaline lustre; the female of this species, although not in our Collection is figured in the ‘Reise der Novara’.2

The females of Apatura laurentia, lavinia and allies have no shot-colouring, but are mimickers of the genus Heterochroa, a group of black, white and orange butterflies.3

The dash of green which you speak of in the females of Ornithoptera is rather a greenish tint in the yellow common to both sexes when seen with the tail to the light; in the same way you will remember that, when held between you and the light and looked at obliquely the same wings are of a golden orange tint.

Believe me to be | Very sincerely yours | Arthur G. Butler

Dr. Ch. Darwin F.R.S. | &c &c &c

Footnotes

No letter in which CD enquired about this butterfly has been found, but CD evidently met Butler at the British Museum to look at butterfly specimens while he was in London between 3 and 11 December (Emma Darwin’s diary (DAR 242), letter to Nature, 16 December 1879). CD’s interest in what is now known as limited-view iridescence had been aroused by the letter from Eduard Schulte, 23 October 1879. Ornithoptera magellanus is a synonym of Troides magellanus, the Magellan birdwing.
See Novara expedition 1861–75, pt 9.2 (2), atlas, tab. 5. The butterfly is listed under the name Papilio magellanus. The yellow-winged group was presumably a group of birdwing butterflies with yellow wings.
Apatura laurentia is a synonym of Doxocopa laurentia, the turquoise emperor; A. lavinia is a synonym of D. lavinia. Heterochroa is a synonym of Adelpha (the genus of sisters).

Summary

Supplies facts on the colours of each sex in butterflies from the genera Ornithoptera and Heterochroa.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-12355
From
Arthur Gardiner Butler
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
British Museum
Source of text
DAR 160: 391
Physical description
ALS 4pp

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 12355,” accessed on 24 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-12355.xml

letter