skip to content

Darwin Correspondence Project

From W. S. Dallas   15 and 16 September 1879

Geological Society

15 Sept. 1879

Dear Mr. Darwin

On consideration I have thought it best to send you the corrected proofs of Krause in order that you may approve of what I have done to them if you think fit, or strike out anything of which you disapprove.—1 You will see that I have adopted nearly all the suggestions that you are so kind as to make, & also that a good many of the errors were misprints.—

I shall send off the German MS. to Krause by this same post & with it the duplicate proofs, to which I have transferred all my marks, requesting him to make any corrections or suggestions that he may think necessary & return the proofs to me.— In the meantime we can send the proofs now forwarded to you to the printers,2 & make use of Dr. Krause’s criticisms upon the revises, which I will read as quickly as possible when I get them.— These first proofs have taken me some time to read, as I had to compare the quotations all through.–

Believe me | Yours very truly | W. S. Dallas

P.S. 16 Sept.— I will add a P.S. to my letter to Dr. Krause as I do not exactly understand what he wants.— I suspect he wanted the MS. to enable him to read the proofs,— if so it will be unnecessary now that he has his own MS. & my corrected proofs.— At p. 143 in a note I queried whether 3 Scallop-shells are your family arms,— the note of interrogation was not intended to be printed, but I am still uncertain whether the statement in the note is admissible.—3

If you will send back the proofs to me, I will forward them to the printers & beg them to let me have the revises as soon as possible.— Shall I get additional revises & have my marks transferred to them to be sent to France & Germany?

W. S. D.

CD annotations

2.4 meantime … printers, 2.5] double scored red crayon
4.4 At … printed, 4.5] scored red crayon
5.2 Shall … Germany? 5.3] scored red crayon
5.3 France] double underlined red crayon
5.3 Germany?] scored red crayon
Bottom of letter: ‘p. 187. I am nearly sure that it was John Hunter—so correct.4 | p 201 a short suggested correction’ ink

Footnotes

Dallas had translated a revised essay by Ernst Krause for Erasmus Darwin (see letter from W. S. Dallas, 13 September 1879).
The note in Erasmus Darwin, p. 143, reads: It was a favourite notion of Dr. Darwin’s that all the lime of the earth originated from living creatures, corals, shells, and other animals, and therefore must have taken part in the pleasures and pains of life. The limestone mountains of England appeared to him as ‘mighty monuments of past delight.’ It was probably in consequence of this idea, and in allusion to his family arms, consisting of three scallop shells, that he altered his motto to ‘E conchis omnia.’ E conchis omnia: everything from shells (Latin).
Erasmus Darwin, p. 187, quotes a passage from Zoonomia that attributes the discovery of crop milk in male and female pigeons to ‘T. Hunter’ (E. Darwin 1794–6, 1: 508); this is corrected in Erasmus Darwin to ‘J. Hunter’. The original source was John Hunter’s essay ‘On a secretion in the crop of breeding pigeons, for the nourishment of their young’ (John Hunter 1786, pp. 191–97). Crop milk is fluid produced by regurgitation at the time when offspring are hatching (see Silver 1984).

Bibliography

Darwin, Erasmus. 1794–6. Zoonomia; or, the laws of organic life. 2 vols. London: J. Johnson.

Hunter, John. 1786. Observations on certain parts of the animal œconomy. London: n.p.

Silver, Rae. 1984. Prolactin and parenting in the pigeon family. Journal of Experimental Zoology 232: 617–25.

Summary

Sends his corrected proofs [of Erasmus Darwin] for CD’s approval, with questions and final arrangements.

Letter details

Letter no.
DCP-LETT-12232
From
William Sweetland Dallas
To
Charles Robert Darwin
Sent from
Geological Society
Source of text
DAR 99: 123–4
Physical description
ALS 4pp †

Please cite as

Darwin Correspondence Project, “Letter no. 12232,” accessed on 16 April 2024, https://www.darwinproject.ac.uk/letter/?docId=letters/DCP-LETT-12232.xml

letter